Uniting Hiring Managers and Recruiters - Collaborative Recruitment Approach
welcome to Talent takeover unfiltered
when it comes to working hard and
keeping it real we know our [ __ ]
self-care happiness inner peace and time
I'm Brianna Rooney and this is Taylor
Bradley hey y'all and we have thrived in
chaos and turn it into an art form so
Taylor what are we doing here today
we're here to give you a raw under the
hood view of all things recruiting and
finally give credit where credit is due
to a long underrated industry that's
full of quote unquote experts all right
well then let's take this show to the
road hello welcome to Talent takeover
unfiltered we have another very special
guest and I will say I don't think one
that we've had um in this role before we
have Ty Lewis who is a VP of engineering
normally we bring in ta and Recruiters
on this but I love what we're talking
about because we want to unite hiring
managers and recruiters how do we do
that and actually I found Ta on LinkedIn
on on uh on on the feed he's just like
speaking to all these great things I'm
like that's a recruiter heart but he's a
VP of engineering I have to talk to him
hey Ty Taylor hi hi thank you for having
me I'm so excited to be here and excited
to chat yeah awesome okay well I mean
like let's just let's just talk about it
what um I guess when in your career
because you've had you've had quite a
great career you know we'll we'll
definitely sh um your LinkedIn so we're
going to check you out but um when in
your career did you decide wow
recruiters are actually my friends CU we
don't hear that often
yeah ah it's very interesting uh very
early in my career I started hiring and
um I I looked to my peers to see how
they were reaching out to candidates how
they were engaging with uh recruiters
and was honestly underwhelmed um I hear
so many of my my peers would talk about
the importance of the relationship with
product managers or the importance of
the relationship with their designers or
their QA counterparts um and they seem
to put so little energy into the the
relationship with their recruiter and um
I I maybe was fortunate um and and I had
just a wonderful recruiting partner who
was easy to talk to and fun and
energetic and the two of us hit it off
and um my roles got hired so much faster
and there was such high quality
candidates coming in and everybody
started looking to me to to ask me what
is different what are you doing and how
is this happening and I
realized uh putting the time and the
energy into the relationship with your
recruiters makes so much of a difference
in terms of uh Ling good candidates
engaging with good candidates um and the
speed at which you can hire people and
so um not only is it fun but it worked
out so much better in terms of filling
my team love it like who would have
thought you have a good relationship and
they do a great job for you
right so do you think that you would
have um Place such an emphasis or value
on having that good relationship with
the recruiter if the recruiter didn't
have like that great energetic
personality or were you like no I know
this is the success to good hiring that
I need to establish this this
relationship with them or was it
specific to that one great recruiter
yeah um it's I mean it's definitely not
specific to that one great recruiter I
think that one great recruiter helped
break the seal for me helped me
understand the importance of this
relationship and since then I've taken
it with me to every recruiter that I've
worked with
um either inh house or um you know
working with sort of any recruiter that
is that is there to help me that um some
aren't quite as energetic some aren't
quite as positive but I still understand
the the importance of a good
relationship there so I think this this
one recruiter just really helped me
understand that a really healthy
relationship can make all the difference
so you really vibed with that one
recruiter but I you mentioned that
there's some recruiters that haven't
been as energetic what steps do you take
if you're you know cuz we talked talk
about how important it is as recruiters
to have this great relationship with the
hiring manager and how to overcome these
challenges with challenging hiring
managers but what steps would you as a
hiring manager take to overcome maybe
and and I'm not articulating this well
but you you're not having the best Vibes
or the dynamic doesn't seem as great or
there maybe the recruiters a little bit
standoffish like what do you do to
overcome that to get to that point in
the relationship where you're you can
have a successful recruitment cycle yeah
it's a good question
um I think there there there are a
couple things that I've done um one and
kind of the easiest one I I don't see
this with a lot of other hiring managers
is just taking the time and making it a
priority to spend time with them um I
think so many H managers are overwhelmed
they have meeting overload they feel
like they don't have any time and so
they don't have time to speak with their
their recruiting partner and taking the
time meeting oneon-one meeting regularly
reviewing resumes together scouring
LinkedIn myself and sending those over
to my recruiting partner and then
talking about them with that person
makes such a difference in kind of
building trust establishing um that
we're doing this together that we are a
partnership um I found to be incredibly
helpful um and I'm an extrovert and so I
like being positive and talking and I'm
a little bit bubbly and so sometimes the
the bubbliness uh is is can can win
people
over I love bubbly like it's you never
hear many people describe themselves as
bubbly it's always like you're
describing someone as bubbly I love that
um you kind of brought me to so I love
the partnership aspect of things because
in recruiting I mean we've definitely
that's what we teach recruiters hey this
is a partnership like this is you know
it doesn't work if you're not you know
um talking together and working it out
and all those things do you feel because
obviously this was this was seems like
more of just your nature you figured out
how you could win in hiring you figured
out how to do it quickly but do you feel
like maybe this should be in hiring
managers kpis you know like they they
their goals should actually be directly
with recruiting and with the recruiting
team in general or like how do you
motivate them to do it like I'm just
thinking like your best case scenario
let's solve for the worst case or even
the average yeah it's interesting um my
immediate response is I don't want to
tell anybody else about this because I I
get so many of the Great candidates as a
result um no I'm just joking I I think
what's really interesting about that
question is it's unfortunate that people
need external motivation to make these
things happen what I've found is when
you take the time the energy working
with your recruiting partner and looking
at LinkedIn and scaring resumés and
brainstorming together um you hire
significantly faster and so you're
saving a lot of time and so it's not
even like it's this big investment that
you're supposed to do and the company's
telling you that it's important it's
it's you win by by taking this time and
energy and investment you are getting
higher quality candidates faster um and
so yes if if this is what people need to
kind of push them over the edge to to
feel comfortable taking the the leap in
doing this then absolutely kpi is great
um I think if people are wanting to hire
high quality candidates and that's the
kpi then I think the solution to that is
build a really strong relationship with
your recruiting partner agreed how do
you so I I know like there's been hiring
managers that have like oh my God I have
like the best recruiter I'm so lucky
like like just like how you're how
you're vibing now but then internally
recruiters get put on different projects
different hiring managers how and then
now you have to redo this relationship
and spending the time and stuff how
would you recommend internally like that
should be
handled um are you asking how companies
should handle it or how a hire a manager
a well maybe just a hiring manager
because it's like you don't want to be
bummed you and you don't want to be like
oh my God that was just a waste of time
like I maybe I'm asking too too too
biger a picture like to suic of a
question here but like I guess it's just
like how can you build rapport quickly
while still getting to your end goal
yeah um one thing that I found I I
worked at both small in big companies um
and so even when I'm at bigger companies
where there's a reasonably sized
recruiting team recruiters talk I found
that when recruiters I think a lot of
recruiters experiences is that their
hiring managers aren't easy to work with
or enjoyable to work with and so when
you are that person um you're talked
about and you stand out and recruiters
tend to like you and so one of the
wonderful things that I've at least
experienced in my you know in my time
doing this is if I'm going from one
recruiter and I've worked with a
recruiter for you know a couple hires
and we've had a great time um and
another recruiter is assigned to me or
something like that um the previous
recruiter will talk to them and often
times they already even know maybe who
the hiring managers are at the company
that are standing out and so sometimes
that alone can be incredibly helpful and
kind of ease the transition um and I
always like having a an initial kickoff
sometimes I do like I do weekly one-on
ones with my recruiters but in the very
beginning it is half an hour or two half
an hour sessions and it is nothing about
recruiting it is nothing about the roles
that we're trying to fill it is just who
we are getting to know each other the
the the positive experiences that we've
had and and just really getting to know
each other as people um I think that's a
huge kind of foundation for this kind of
relationship and if we jump so quickly
into this is what I need from you and
this is how quickly I need it uh I think
just you get off on the wrong foot it's
like music to my ears I can't even like
when you're saying we just spend an hour
getting to know each other I'm like what
like in in any roles who does that these
days which I think it's so there's so
much value in that um that approach but
I was wondering so is this internal
recruiters that you're talking about
like the the dynamic is that who you
work with primarily uh yeah it's a good
question
um primarily yes um but not exclusively
um I've I've a lot of what I've been
talking about applies to all Rec
Critters um I've done this with folks
internally externally um I I mean I and
one of the the things that's sort of
interesting about one of the things you
were saying just before this is um I
think it's a little bit different in a
remote world I think when we were in
person and recruiters are you know
you're you're talking you go out to
lunch you have you get coffee you spend
some time together it's easier it's more
natural to take that time to get to know
them and in a remote world where
everyone is stuck in meetings all day
long and doesn't want to spend more time
in meetings that's the last thing that
people want to do is just have get to
know you time and um so I think that
that is is important um but I think that
is important regardless of if that
person is internal or external I think
the the only complication is some like
if if that external partner is not
someone who you're going to be working
with for a long period of Time It's
Different um yeah and and I think it you
know depends if you're working with a
team of people and but also I I think
these are these are important
relationships and these are important
conversations um and you know it's kind
of fun yeah that was going to be part
two of my question was like do you apply
the same approach with external as you
do as internal and you said yes um so it
sounds like that's the case but it's how
would you recommend that hiring managers
stick to your approach or do an approach
like this whenever or take an approach
like this whenever they will be working
with different recruiters whatever so
whenever I did internal recruiting we
tried to align like this is the
recruiter that recruits for sales this
is the recruiter that recruits for
engineering like you try to align it to
we the same recruiters is going to work
with the same hiring managers and an
effort that they'll want to build those
relationships that they'll have that
report CU I imagine that would get hard
and people would be less motivated to
want to establish the relationships and
to get to know you and spend that time
if they're like I'm just going to have
another recruit a different recruiter
next time you know so do you do you
recommend aligning to where you're
working with the same recruiter is that
approach that you would take yeah I
think
so or are you like I like to get to know
different people so I'm I don't mind
working with different recruiters even
though so and so is a proven recruiter
we have a great relationship bring on
any
newbies yeah I I mean it's it's a good
question and I don't know that I have a
one answer I think yeah it depends a
little bit um I think Rapport has a lot
to do with it and having Rapport might
be might be more important than someone
who has a particular Specialties if
you've been working with them and just
have a great Rapport and have hired a
bunch of folks together um but I also
think it's as a hiring manager probably
as a recruiting partner as well um it's
it's really important to be able to get
good at building rapport with folks
quickly and so having that experience
and having more repetitions doing that
is also a a great skill to be developing
because if you're a higher manager now
you're likely going to be a higher
manager later and you'll continue to
work with lots and less of recruiters
and the more reps you have building
these relationships I think is really
good so how would you recommend training
highering managers and I'm very
selfishly asking so we have like we uh
we were thinking as from the recruiting
standpoint it's like look this is broken
this relationship doesn't exist like it
should like you said hiring managers
don't take the time and essentially it's
like you could give a little to get a
lot right but like you have to show them
data and so we developed hiring manager
training and we're like oh this is going
to sell like hot cakes because this is
like we have to make this faster we have
to make it a more enjoyable experience
and it's like we got crickets over here
right so obviously companies don't want
to you know do training for Hing
managers but I feel and let seems like
you feel the same way this actually
could be super valuable so like just
let's just say you're the trainer of all
hiring managers because you've got
you've got it going on what would you
really um what training would they be
going through and and what would be what
would feel worth their time it's not a
sexual harassment training certification
right this is like this is real stuff
that you could use at every single
company yeah it's it's a really
interesting question before I answer
that I'm I'm kind of curious why was
there not reception to what you shared
with with companies well so they because
they were treating it like a sexual
harassment training we're okay we're
going to take all of like our hiring
managers and it was like hey can we just
have like a digital course yeah you
could or we could align it and roleplay
on what's actually going on in the
organization what is the challenges hey
let me uh let me take a survey of the
recruiting team and the hiring managers
let's figure out what's broken because
it's not a one-size fits-all situation
but I remember um when Tay and I were
building this um she was like there's no
way companies are going to let their guy
Hing managers they're they get paid the
most sit through four to 6 hours and
role play and like figure this out and I
and I was constantly like why not but
Taylor you're probably better to answer
this because you were on that page yeah
so I I've worked with clients pretty big
clients that required all their hiring
managers to go through hiring manager
interview training like it was it was a
requirement it was one of their goals
they had to do it and it was all day
long and they had to sit through role
plays and they I mean they hated it it
was like pulling teeth but they were so
efficient so at hiring it was also they
had slas built into their goals about
being responsive and providing feedback
within you know 48 hours and they're
just it they had an amazing hiring
process and like won awards for um their
approach to recruitment but I think
oftentimes companies don't really going
back to like what we said in the
beginning of this conversation hiring
managers and com companies and some
hiring managers don't really see the
value in recruiting or think it's like
how hard is it to go find me people you
know just go out there like they don't
want to invest the time this is not
where they feel they need to invest time
in so it wasn't one of those things
where people are like I need this
training no no one was raising their
hand to take it and then I yeah having
been in corporate for so long I was
telling Brandon no no companies that I
know minus that one with that being the
exception are going they value
recruiting enough to take their hiring
managers or or employees out of
production for a whole day or half a day
or whatever it is to put them through
this so they should value it in summary
it's so interesting as a as a hiring
manager and I'll answer your question in
a minute but as as a hire manager one of
the things or maybe even as a
engineering leader one of the things
that I've been told so so many times is
you should be spending 40 to 50% of your
time recruiting if that's true if I'm
spending nearly half of my time
recruiting how can this not be a
priority and how can these kinds of
relationships and the process and the
quality of candidates that we're looking
for and the quality of the relationship
which results in you know better quality
candidates and so on not be important um
and also what's interesting is I am
responsible for the time of my the
engineers on my team or at least when it
comes to recruiting and so if I'm
sending candidates to folks that are on
my team and they're low quality then I
am wasting their time as well um which
is which is very interesting to me
because as a hiring manager um it's it's
important but as a engineering manager
just a manager of people it feels like a
horrible use of time to not be spending
the time
doing I mean all of these things which
is really interesting yeah well think
about how many managers are actually
trained internally you know like think
about who's actually made a manager oh
the person who did this job the best is
or who's been here the longest okay
great you're a manager it was never like
hey do you like to lead do you like to
Mentor what's your what's your theory on
this I mean like I know take you speak
to that a lot on how you can be a good
manager I mean I this goes like this is
literally goes hand inand and the lack
of training it does it does and and
what's interesting is going to your
earlier question of what would I include
in the training I think a lot of it is
starting with the outcomes because um I
find recruiting to be fun not a lot of
engineering leaders find recruiting to
be fun and so for me it's intrinsically
it's just like yeah let's do this this
this is going to be great um but that's
not the reason that I do it the reason
that I do it is because the quality of
candidates is higher when you build
strong relationships when you can work
really well with your recruiting partner
they have a much much much better
understanding of what you're looking for
and so often recruiting managers aren't
technical I'm I'm in a technical role
I'm looking for technical people it's
it's really hard to have them know what
I'm looking for if I'm not spending a
lot of time talking to them
brainstorming with them giving them
feedback on the candidates that they're
sending in um and I think sometimes
giving feedback on the candidates that
they're that they're sending to me that
takes trust and trust is built you
establish that by having a good
relationship um and the other one in
terms of outcomes is I hire much faster
I there's for many reasons um one is the
quality of the candidates is just higher
and so when you have higher quality can
is coming into the funnel you're more
likely to land somebody um and I was
talking with Brian about this earlier
but this is my little known secret so
don't tell anybody um sly oh
well are we live okay
um but when I'm working especially at
bigger companies where there's multiple
recruiters and I have an open role and
I'm amongst 10 other hiring managers
that have open roles when the hiring
manager and I have a really good
relationship and a great Dynamic and
there's a candidate that comes in that
they know is a great fit for me and they
don't really understand if it's a great
fit for some of the other roles because
they don't have as good of an
understanding they send them to me even
if I'm not the priority hire even if
they shouldn't be sending it to me and
so I I skipped the
line and and and it's it's fantastic
it's it's it's fun you get incredible
candidates and um and I don't think it's
well can argue if it's fair or it's
unfair but I think just the more that
you can really help your recruiting
partner know like get into your mind of
what you're looking for and what makes a
good candidate on your team and why are
the why are the current employees on the
team doing well and what does it mean to
thrive and all those kinds of things
mean that the kinds of candidates that
you're going to get are just going to be
a better fit for what you're looking
for managers leave and join I mean sorry
people leave and join companies because
of managers you know and so it's like
you can highlight like you know like oh
my God Ty's amazing so if I'm talking to
a candidate I'm GNA pop him up like oh
my God T so amazing the way that he he
leads and mentors he really cares like
he's built a relationship with me he'll
build it with you like that would be my
prep right cuz that's my job my job is
to prep people well I've also had to
prep on the other side hey you know what
this hireing manager means well but
comes across a little aggressive just to
let you know you know it's like hm which
one is which way is a candidate gonna go
right you know what's the easier sell
yeah little bit easier I so we're coming
up on time so I think I know I would
love to hear as I know our listeners
would what is your broke to boss
tip ah it's it's a great question I I
mean I think so much of what we've
talked about kind of rolls up into this
but if you want to hire faster and if
you want to hire better quality
candidates invest in your relationship
with your recruiting partner you said
that during the conversation I was like
that's a bro to bosson that's such a
good one from a hiring manager's
perspective invest in that relationship
if you want to hire faster and get the
best quality can I love it so I'm going
to go against the grain here for a
second because I cannot leave this
conversation listeners you will thank me
for this what can a recruiter do though
to make themselves a great partner I
just want to touch on that really
quickly and I know we're out of time but
I have to yeah it's a it's a very good
question um and I I welcome the question
because I don't get that one very often
um be curious about what the hiring
manager is looking for and I think I I
think i' I've found a lot of recruiting
or some some recruiting partners that do
this very well where they really want to
get to know me they really want to get
to know the team they really want to get
to know what are the kinds of candidates
that are or the kinds of employees that
are thriving at the company um and when
they do that it opens up the hireing
manager the hireing manager love like
people love to respond to questions like
that and when especially when they get
to talk about themselves with their own
team and so when when those questions
are brought to the H manager they get to
say this is what's great about the team
or this is what's good about you know
this kind of candidate and I feel like
that Curiosity leads to really
interesting
conversations perfect love that and love
that another episode Taylor was just
talking about how she always has to ask
the why so that's a great quality
recruiters ask why ask how yep like
Taylor thank you so much um and we will
see you you know every single week but
great great great nuggets reunite tyer
managers and HS that's right thank you
for having me this is a ton of fun
thanks
y'all